Serving Guilford, CT

Book Free Appointment Call (203) 717-4921

Licensed Connecticut Dealer Insured through Lloyd's of London Free Evaluations Same-Day Payment

Why Guilford Residents Make the Twenty-Five-Minute Drive

Guilford has jewelers on the Green and along Route 1, and buyers in Madison and Branford are close by. We are not going to pretend they do not exist. What brings Guilford families 25 minutes up I-95 to our counter is the evaluation itself. As a licensed Connecticut buy-only dealer, we have no retail floor and no reason to underquote a coin we might eventually resell. The number on your written offer is the number we honor.

Every coin is set out on the counter and graded individually while you observe. For bullion pieces, we pull live spot pricing, weigh the coin, and walk through the math. For numismatic coins, the date, mint mark, and condition are identified, then checked against the same pricing references we use at resale. You see every step and carry home a written offer with no obligation to decide on the spot.

Connecticut law requires payment by check, and you receive your check the same day you accept our offer. The evaluation is always free, whether you sell or not.

Coins We Evaluate from Guilford Collections

Inherited collections and estate coins

Guilford’s affluent, long-tenured households — from Sachem’s Head to the Green-area colonials — produce collections that sometimes span four or five generations. Estates turn over with silver dollars in bank wrappers, wheat cents in jars, and proof sets in original Mint envelopes. We price every coin on its own merits, never as a bulk lot.

Colonial and early U.S. coins

Guilford’s 1639 founding means some families have held coins since the colonial era. We evaluate Massachusetts coppers, Spanish silver reales, half cents, and large cents — pieces that predate the U.S. Mint. These require specialized references and experience to identify and grade, and we have both. If you have something old and are not even sure it is a coin, bring it.

Morgan and Peace silver dollars

Morgan Dollars (1878–1921) and Peace Dollars (1921–1935) turn up frequently in Guilford estates. Value hinges on date, mint mark, and condition — an 1881-S in average grade trades near silver, while an 1893-S uncirculated can reach five figures. We identify each dollar on the counter.

Pre-1965 silver coins

U.S. dimes, quarters, and half dollars dated 1964 and earlier are 90 percent silver. We weigh the lot, pull live spot, and show you the math. Some dates carry numismatic value above silver — we identify those rather than pricing the whole lot at melt.

Wheat and Indian Head cents

Lincoln wheat cents (1909–1958) and Indian Head cents (1859–1909) appear regularly from Guilford estates. Most wheat cents trade in bulk, but key dates like the 1909-S VDB and 1914-D can be worth many times face. We check every cent for key dates before quoting.

Mercury dimes and Walking Liberty halves

Mercury dimes (1916–1945) and Walking Liberty halves (1916–1947) have genuine numismatic following. The 1916-D Mercury dime and 1916 Walking Liberty half are key dates worth far more than silver. We identify date and mint mark, grade, and price accordingly.

Proof and mint sets

Sealed proof and mint sets are a staple of Guilford collections, many bought by parents and grandparents over decades. Value depends on year, set type, and whether coins retain original toning. We open each set, confirm contents, and price against current market values.

Paper currency

We also evaluate U.S. paper currency — silver certificates, Federal Reserve notes, large-size currency, and star notes. Condition and series year drive value. Bring any alongside your coins.

World coins from family

Guilford’s shoreline location and seasonal residents mean we see European and Canadian coins brought back by family. Some carry silver or gold; others have collectible value in their home market. We identify country, denomination, metal, and condition, then price accordingly.

Grading and condition

A coin’s grade — condition on a 70-point scale — is the biggest factor in numismatic value after rarity. We grade each coin on the counter while you observe. The difference between Fine-12 and MS-63 can be dramatic.

Do not clean your coins

Leave your coins exactly as you found them. Polishing or dipping removes the surface toning collectors prize, and a cleaned coin is worth less — sometimes dramatically less. This is especially critical for colonial copper, where original color is paramount. Bring them as-is.

Whole-collection evaluation

If you have inherited or accumulated a collection — colonial coins, proof sets, silver dollars, foreign pieces — bring all of it. We sort by category, grade each coin, and price individually. You see the breakdown and take home a written offer.

The 10-day hold

Connecticut requires a 10-day hold on certain non-bullion items — a consumer protection giving you time to reconsider. The hold applies to when we can resell, not when you get paid. Bullion is exempt. You get your check the same day.

Coin Collections in Guilford

Guilford is an affluent shoreline town of about 22,000 in New Haven County, home to one of the largest town greens in New England. The Henry Whitfield House (1639), the oldest stone house in New England, anchors a community with deep colonial roots. Sachem’s Head, Chaffinch Island, Jacobs Beach, and Leete’s Island dot the coastline, and the Guilford Fair draws crowds each fall.

The town’s long-tenured households and retiree population produce estates with collections that go back generations — colonial coppers from Green-area colonials, silver dollars from the early twentieth century, and gold bullion coins bought as a hedge in the 1970s and 1980s. These accumulations come out of estate clear-outs when a family home near the Green or along the shore changes hands.

Guilford is bordered by Branford to the west, North Branford to the northwest, Madison to the east, and Durham to the north. Sellers from these neighboring towns reach our Whitney Avenue counter in about 25 minutes via I-95. Beyond coins, we also acquire gold jewelry, sterling silver, watches, and bullion — bring everything together and we evaluate each category on its own.

What We Buy

See everything we buy

Questions from Guilford Residents

Straight answers to the questions we hear most from Guilford sellers.

Getting to Haven Coin from Guilford

Two easy routes from Guilford to our Hamden location at 2285 Whitney Ave.

Helpful Resources for Guilford Sellers

Everything you need to know before your visit.

Sell Coins in Connecticut

What Connecticut law requires, how to prepare your collection, and what to expect at an evaluation.

Learn more

Selling Inherited Coins

A guide for executors and family members navigating an inherited coin collection in Connecticut.

Learn more

Appraisals

Professional written appraisals for insurance, estate settlement, and equitable distribution.

Learn more

What to Do with an Inherited Coin Collection

Practical steps for sorting, evaluating, and selling coins inherited from a family member.

Read guide

How Coin Appraisals Work

What goes into a professional coin appraisal — grading, market research, and the written report.

Read guide

Morgan Silver Dollar Value Guide

What Morgan dollars are worth by date, mint mark, and condition — from common to key.

Read guide

Should You Clean Old Coins?

Why cleaning coins reduces their value, and what to do instead before bringing them to a dealer.

Read guide

Ready to Visit from Guilford?

The drive up I-95 from Guilford takes about 25 minutes. Bring whatever coins, currency, gold, or sterling you have. Free evaluation, same-day payment, no pressure.

Content by Matt Pavia, Licensed CT Precious Metals Dealer & ANA Member — Licensed, insured, and committed to fair, professional service. Hours: Tue–Fri 10–5, Sat 10–2.