Selling Gold & Silver
Do You Pay Taxes When You Sell Gold or Silver? The IRS Rate Can Be Higher Than You Think
Selling a gold coin for $2,000 does not automatically mean the IRS taxes you on $2,000.
What matters is what happened between the day you acquired it and the day you sold it. If you paid $1,500 and later sold it for $2,000, the important number for tax purposes is generally the $500 gain, not the full selling price. If you inherited the gold, received it as a gift, or no longer know what was originally paid, figuring out that gain can become more complicated.
Gold and silver also have a tax rule that surprises many people. The IRS can treat long-term gains on coins and precious-metal bullion as collectibles, which means the federal maximum rate can be higher than the familiar long-term capital-gains rates people often hear about for stocks.

Tax Is Generally Based on Your Gain, Not the Sale Price
According to IRS Publication 550, gold, silver, coins, and similar investment property are generally capital assets when they are owned by an investor rather than held as inventory by a dealer. When you sell a capital asset, you compare what you received with your adjusted basis. IRS Publication 544 explains the basic rule: if the amount you realize is more than your adjusted basis, you have a gain. If your basis is higher, you have a loss.
For something you purchased yourself, basis usually begins with what you paid. IRS Publication 551 explains that certain acquisition costs can also become part of basis. That is why an old receipt can become surprisingly important years after the gold or silver was purchased.
Suppose someone bought a gold coin for $1,800 and later sold it for $2,300. Ignoring other adjustments for a simple example, the gain would be about $500. The $2,300 check is not itself a $2,300 profit.
Short-Term Gains and the 28% Collectibles Rate
How long you owned the metal changes the federal tax treatment. IRS Topic No. 409 says that an asset held for one year or less generally creates a short-term capital gain or loss. Net short-term capital gains are taxed at ordinary income tax rates.
Hold the asset for more than one year, and the gain is generally long term. This is where precious metals become different from many other investments.
The IRS Schedule D instructions specifically include gold, silver, and platinum bullion and coins within the collectibles rules. Net long-term gains from collectibles can be taxed at a maximum federal rate of 28%.
That word “maximum” matters.
It does not mean everyone who makes money selling a gold coin owes exactly 28% of the gain. Your actual federal tax depends on your taxable income, other capital gains and losses, and the rest of your tax situation. The IRS describes 28% as the maximum rate applicable to net capital gains from collectibles. An additional 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax may apply depending on your income and filing status, so 28% is not necessarily the maximum total federal tax burden.
This can surprise someone who has heard that long-term capital gains are normally taxed at 0%, 15%, or 20%. Precious metals and collectible coins can fall under a different set of capital-gain rules.
What Happens When You Sell Inherited Gold?
Inherited gold creates another common misunderstanding.
If your grandfather bought a gold coin for $100 decades ago and you inherit it when it is worth $2,000, your basis is generally not automatically his original $100 cost.
IRS Publication 551 says the basis of inherited property is generally its fair market value on the date of the owner’s death. If the estate properly elects an alternate valuation date, that value may be used instead. Certain estates also provide beneficiaries with Schedule A of Form 8971, and the beneficiary may be required to use a basis consistent with the estate-tax value shown there.
Imagine, as a simple example, that inherited gold had a fair market value of $2,000 on the date of death and was later sold for $2,200. The starting point for calculating the gain would generally be around the inherited basis of $2,000, not what the original owner may have paid decades earlier.
There are exceptions and additional estate rules, which is one reason inherited collections can be worth discussing with a tax professional before they are sold. Inherited capital assets generally receive long-term capital-gain treatment regardless of how long you personally held them.
What If You Do Not Know Your Purchase Price?
A different problem comes up when you bought the gold yourself but have no idea what you paid.
Do not simply invent a number.
IRS Publication 551 says taxpayers must keep accurate records of the items that affect basis. The Instructions for Form 8949 similarly say that you need your basis to calculate gain or loss and should maintain records showing amounts such as purchase price and commissions.
If the original receipt is gone, look for whatever legitimate records still exist. Old invoices, dealer receipts, bank or credit-card records, estate paperwork, and other documentation may help establish what happened. If the amount cannot be determined confidently, a tax professional can help determine what documentation is usable rather than guessing at a basis that cannot be supported.
Taxes on Personal Jewelry
Jewelry follows another rule that often catches people off guard.
IRS Publication 544 lists gems and jewelry among examples of capital assets. If you sell personal jewelry for more than your adjusted basis, the gain can be taxable.
But the opposite does not work the same way.
The IRS says a loss from selling personal-use property is generally not deductible. So if someone bought a gold necklace for $3,000, wore it for years, and later sold it for $1,500, that personal loss generally does not become a $1,500 capital-loss deduction.
If that same necklace had somehow increased in value and was sold for a gain, the gain can still be taxable.
Do Coin Dealers Report Sales to the IRS?
Then there is the question almost every precious-metals seller eventually asks: Does the coin dealer report my sale to the IRS?
The answer is not simply “every sale” or “no sales.”
The IRS Instructions for Form 1099-B contain specific reporting rules for precious metals. In general, a broker may have Form 1099-B reporting obligations for certain sales of gold, silver, platinum, or palladium when the metal is in a form approved for delivery under a Commodity Futures Trading Commission-regulated futures contract and the quantity sold reaches the applicable contract minimum.
The IRS instructions also contain exceptions. If the precious metal is not in a form approved for such a futures contract, the sale is not reportable under that rule. Even an approved form generally is not reportable if the quantity is below the minimum required to satisfy the applicable futures contract.
The IRS gives a simple example: selling one gold coin does not require Form 1099-B merely because that type of coin could qualify for delivery when the relevant futures contract requires at least 25 coins.
Sales for the same customer within a 24-hour period are aggregated when applying this rule, and the exception does not apply when a broker knows or has reason to know that transactions are being structured to avoid information reporting.
Those rules are about the dealer’s information-reporting obligation. They do not decide whether your gain is taxable.
IRS Publication 544 makes that distinction clear: whether or not you receive Form 1099-B, you are still responsible for reporting taxable sales when the tax rules require it. A transaction does not become tax-free simply because no information form was issued.
Connecticut Income Tax on Gold and Silver Sales
Connecticut residents also need to think about state income tax.
The Connecticut Department of Revenue Services says Connecticut gross income includes capital gains. Connecticut adjusted gross income generally begins with federal adjusted gross income and then applies the specific Connecticut additions and subtractions required on the state return.
So a federally taxable gain from selling gold or silver can also affect a Connecticut resident’s state income tax. The exact result depends on the taxpayer’s overall Connecticut return and any applicable state modifications. This is separate from the sales-tax rules that can apply when products are purchased.
Records to Keep Before and After Selling
Recordkeeping makes every part of this easier.
Keep purchase receipts, invoices, dates, quantities, descriptions of the coins or bullion, and records showing what you paid. If you inherit precious metals, keep estate documents, valuations, and any Schedule A from Form 8971 you receive. When you sell, keep the dealer’s written offer, sale receipt, payment record, and any tax form associated with the transaction.
Those records can help answer the two numbers the tax calculation eventually needs: what was your basis, and what did you receive when you sold?

Know What Your Coins and Metals Are Worth
Before taking a collection anywhere, also separate ordinary bullion from collectible coins. Taxes are only one reason. A common one-ounce gold bar is usually evaluated differently from a rare U.S. gold coin whose collector value may be far higher than its metal content. The same applies to silver dollars, key dates, certified coins, and unusual varieties.
For anyone in Connecticut or the surrounding area, Haven Coin & Jewelry at 2285 Whitney Ave in Hamden buys gold and silver coins, bullion, jewelry, sterling silverware, and full estate collections. Evaluations are free, in person, and there is no obligation to sell. Items are tested and weighed in front of the customer and priced individually against live market information. Customers are given a written figure to keep.
Walk-ins are welcome Tuesday through Friday from 10am–5pm and Saturday from 10am–2pm. For a larger collection, call (203) 717-4921 to arrange an appointment.
Find your reputable dealer!
Your Sale Proceeds and Your Tax Bill Are Different
Haven can evaluate the metals, but your individual tax situation is a separate question. Tax treatment can depend on how you acquired the property, your basis, how long you owned it, whether it was personal or investment property, and what else appears on your tax return.
The check you receive tells you what the gold or silver sold for.
It does not, by itself, tell you what you owe in tax.
For that, keep your records and check with a qualified tax professional who can apply the current IRS and Connecticut rules to your specific situation.
FAQ: Taxes on Selling Gold and Silver
Do I have to pay taxes on gold I sell?
You may owe tax if you sell gold for more than your adjusted basis. IRS Publication 544 explains that the gain is generally the amount realized above your basis, rather than the entire sale price.
What is the tax rate on selling gold?
It depends on the situation. Short-term capital gains are generally taxed at ordinary income rates. IRS Topic No. 409 says net long-term gains on collectibles can be taxed at a maximum federal rate of 28%. Your actual rate may be lower. An additional 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax may apply depending on your income and filing status.
Do I pay tax on inherited gold?
Selling inherited gold can create a taxable gain. IRS Publication 551 says inherited property generally receives a basis equal to its fair market value on the date of death, subject to exceptions and certain estate-tax valuation rules. Compare that basis with the eventual selling price to determine the gain.
Do coin dealers report to the IRS?
Some precious-metal transactions can trigger Form 1099-B reporting under the IRS rules, while others do not. The requirements depend on the form and quantity of metal and other circumstances described in the IRS Instructions for Form 1099-B. Whether or not a Form 1099-B is issued, the seller remains responsible for reporting taxable gains.
Visit Haven in Hamden
Know what you have.
Understand what it’s worth.
Ready to get a professional evaluation? Visit us at 2285 Whitney Ave, Hamden CT or call (203) 717-4921.
Book Free Appointment Hours & directions